Trickle-Down Economics Remains an Unsuccessful Approach

Trickle-down economics continues to get a lot of airplay in conservatively led states such as NC, which is unfortunate, as it has been proven to be an unsuccessful approach to economic growth. In a recent speech at the Center for American Progress, Maryland Gov. Martin O’Malley took aim at trickle-down economics — the conservative theory that fiscal policies benefiting upper earners will improve the whole economy and therefore also benefit the middle and lower classes. “Trickle-down economics has been an abject failure for 99% of Americans,” O’Malley said, according to prepared remarks. “If we want to deliver better results — if we want to strengthen our middle class and expand middle class opportunity — then we have to be willing to make better choices.”

As governor, O’Malley has a strong base of success to speak from. Yet, he does not stand alone in this opinion. The Congressional Research Service, the nonpartisan think tank for Congress, prepared a report on their analysis of the veracity of trickle-down economics and was to release it last fall. The report agrees with the assertion made by O’Malley above. The reason it did not get much airplay is Senator Mitch McConnell had the report buried before the election according to the New York Times.

Yet, a better source may be David Stockman who was budget director to President Reagan. Stockman claimed that trickle-down economics was a favored economic tradition, believing it would benefit the entire country over time. Of course, he did not say that everyone would benefit equally or adequately. Over time, many felt they had been left out of the promised glory. Today, Stockman has a different view from the one he had then. He is on record saying trickle down economics did not work and I have seen him say it.

Even going in Stockman should have read more history.The idea that trickle-down economics is good for the country was ridiculed by economist John Kenneth Galbraith and even FDR. They said that it had been tried in the past and failed. According to Galbraith, it was known as the “horse and sparrow theory.” He said that “If you feed the horse enough oats, some will pass through to the road for the sparrows” and  believed that this idea lead to an economic crisis referred to as the “Panic of 1896.”

Let’s not take Stockman and Galbraith’s retrospective insight by themselves. This belief is also echoed by Nobel Award winning economist Paul Krugman. And, you may want to check out Mehrun Etebari’s article published on June 17, 2003 entitled: “Trickle Down Economics: Four Reasons Why It Just Doesn’t Work.” His thesis is by any of four major measures – GDP growth, Income growth, Wage growth or Improvement in un-employment, trickle-down economics fails to deliver. Here is a link to the article: http://www.faireconomy.org/research/TrickleDown.html.

Two closing thoughts. First, the best comment about trickle-down economics actually comes from one George H.W. Bush (which he borrowed from journalist Paul Harvey) when he was running against Ronald Reagan and before he became his Vice President. Bush referred to it as “Voodoo Economics.” Harvey and Bush were correct.

Second, if people are looking for an economic theory that does promote growth, look to Keynesian economics. People refer to stimulating the economy through government investment as strictly Keynesian economics. The Obama Stimulus was Keynesian economics and unlike what has been drummed into an electorate by the GOP last year, the “Failed Stimulus” actually worked. Who says so? Six economic organizations do – Macroeconomics Advisors, Moody’s Economy.com, IHS Global Insight, JP Morgan Chase, Goldman Sachs and the Congressional Budget Office. They said it improved the economy and would have been even more successful if it was larger.

So, let’s sum up. The GOP is touting an economic approach – trickle-down economics that has been proven not to work.The only people who will benefit from reducing taxes on the rich are the rich. Keynesian economics has been proven to work including the Obama Stimulus plan, which the GOP was able to convince others it did not, even with evidence to the contrary. I think the Democrats need a better press agent.

12 thoughts on “Trickle-Down Economics Remains an Unsuccessful Approach

    • They are proposing it in NC as we speak. The press and others have been calling it what it is, but they are pushing. A GOP State Senator wrote an Op-ed piece that was derogatory toward the liberal press daring to throw water on the idea. And, you are correct, it certainly should be.

      • The Business Journal online news did an informal survey and the NC General Assembly got an “F” grade by 41% and a “D” grade by 14%. By my math that totals 55%. I read yesterday, our cousin to the south, South Carolina has declined to 3rd worst in poverty with their 874,000 citizens in poverty making up 19% of the population. Mississippi is actually doing better on this measure than than SC. And, yet the platform of GOP leadership does nothing for them.

    • Thanks for sharing this Mrs. N. It is an excellent read. Every store clerk is pushing more purchases wnile you are trying to pay for what you bought. Yesterday after telling a cashier she did her job well by offering me another product, she said “but you did not buy anything.” I told her “I don’t want it. Just because I can buy it, doesn’t mean I should.” This pursuit of “things” is driving us to missing the important issues. Thanks again for commenting. BTG

  1. Note to Readers: You can add Kansas to the example of failures of Trickle Down economics. They are struggling since the policy was put in place. In North Carolina, it was noted early on what the legislature did was hike overall taxes for lesser paid folks along with the cutback for higher up folks. It was a sleight of hand move. So, recovery has lagged the national recovery. As a citizen, much of our success is in spite of our legislature which bickers and impedes progress.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.