Two movie reviews – one must see, one must not

We have a wonderful, locally and colorfully run video store in my city. It is organized in a genre fashion, with new releases on one wall. The manager and staff are eclectic people with large hearts and extensive movie knowledge, so it makes it a fun excursion when we go. We stopped by and picked up a couple of new releases to view this long weekend – “August: Osage County” and “The Book Thief.” I will not spoil these movies, but provide observations of what is in store for you if you rent them.

“August: Osage County” is a well-directed and well acted movie about one of the most dysfunctional families you will witness. We rented it because of the talented list of actors: Meryl Streep, Julia Roberts, Chris Cooper, Ewan McGregor, Dermot Mulroney, Abigail Breslin, Juliette Lewis, Benedict Cumberbatch, Margo Martindale, Sam Shepard, Julianne Nicholson, et al. With that said, unless your goal is to watch a loud and hateful train wreck of a family to make you feel better about your own challenges, my suggestion is to put it back on the shelf. There are only three redeeming characters in the whole movie, with all the others cursing and yelling throughout.

On the flip side, “The Book Thief” was a terrific movie based on the novel by Markus Zusak and set in Nazi Germany prior to and through World War II. Liesel is an adopted girl whose little brother dies on the train ride to their adopted family. She becomes the book thief, as she wants to learn to read and is encouraged by her adopted Papa and a young Jewish man, Max, who they are hiding in their basement. Liesel is played by Sophie Nelisse, while Geoffrey Rush plays a very kind-hearted Papa to his wife’s pragmatic and cool Mama played by Emily Watson. Ben Schnetzer plays Max.

Liesel is befriended by a young boy Rudy who is loyal to her. Yet, she has to keep the secret of their family’s hiding of Max or all of them will get in trouble. So, she cannot tell even Rudy until he surmises later what’s happening. The key to the movie is her love of books and how they are essential to keeping their humanity when all around them human decency is under brutal attack. This love of reading befriends her to even the burgermeister’s wife who helps because of her own love of reading, at a time when books are being burned. The woman observes Liesel saving a book from a smoldering fire as she looks on forelornly.

So, I would highly recommend the latter movie and advise you to stay away from the former. “The Book Thief” is also well acted, but the story has characters and a plot that have redeeming value to them.  While drawn to Sophie, I particularly liked Rush’s Papa character. If you have seen either or both movies, I would love to hear your thoughts. Also, if you read “The Book Thief” which I have not, please let me know how it stacks up to the movie and vice-versa.


9 thoughts on “Two movie reviews – one must see, one must not

  1. Here in Vienna, the first movie is playing and we were toying with the idea of seeing it. Now we won’t bother! However, I read The Book Thief and loved it, and the movie is playing on the airplane, so on the flight home I will watch it. Thanks for the timely reviews!

    • Emily, I hope you are having a delightful time. Vienna is a city I want to visit. After you see “The Book Thief” let me know how it compares to the novel. Have a great trip, BTG

  2. Pingback: Two movie reviews - one must see, one must not | Tinseltown Times

    • Judy, my wife wants to see this. So, we will probably venture out. We also want to see Philomena with Judi Dench. Looks like a great story. I am enjoying your alphabet soup this month. Thanks, BTG

  3. Amazing! I didn’t know anyone still went to video stores. There are hardly any left..more rare even than bookstores. Good to know about Osage. I think I may have started to stream that one from Netflix, lured by the cast, but didn’t get past the first 30 minutes. At least that happened recently, but I don’t remember the name of the movie. I’ve heard many good things about The Book Thief, but missed it when it was in town. Glad to know it’s out on DVD now.

    • Linda, you would love this store. Its staff is colorfully tattooed with various piercings, various hair colors and styles. They are warm hearted, helpful and knowledgeable. I try to support local businesses. They will have a whole section on British or French films or one on Drama and one on Intrigue. They even have a display of employee picks and their stars will carry with the case when refiled by genre. They will have Hitchcock section and a Agatha Christie section, e.g. Sometimes, we will get a movie like August: Osage County and do what you did and make it through twenty minutes. Happy Trails, BTG

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.