Tapping immigrants to help growth

In a recent post, I commented that some US towns are recruiting immigrants to help restart economic progress. Here is an AI search summary which provides some examples:

“Several small to mid-sized U.S. towns and cities have actively recruited or welcomed immigrants and refugees to stabilize populations and revitalize local economies facing decline due to loss of manufacturing and agricultural jobs.

Towns and Cities with Recruitment Efforts

Utica, New York – Since the 1970s, Utica has resettled over 17,000 refugees through the Mohawk Valley Resource Center for Refugees (now The Center), which helped reverse a significant population decline after factories closed.

Topeka, Kansas – The city’s ‘Choose Topeka’ program provides financial incentives of up to $15,000 for remote workers and local business employees, including specific marketing campaigns targeting Hispanic workers to address labor shortages.

Galesburg, Illinois – Historically, Galesburg attracted European immigrants and Mexican railroad workers (known as ‘Boxcar People’) for labor. In recent years, local organizations and educational institutions have focused on supporting immigrant integration to foster economic revitalization.

Erie, Pennsylvania – This city actively participates in refugee resettlement programs, viewing the absorption of newcomers as crucial for its demographic and economic vitality.

Greenport, New York – In the 1990s, a revitalization effort led to an influx of Hispanic immigrants who filled blue-collar jobs in construction and landscaping, helping to transform a struggling ‘dead end’ town into a thriving village.

Rural Meatpacking Communities (e.g., Schuyler, Nebraska, and Worthington, Minnesota) – In the 1990s, these towns saw a large influx of immigrants drawn by job opportunities in the meatpacking industry, which helped sustain local workforces.

Clarkston, Georgia – Known as a major refugee resettlement area in the Deep South, Clarkston has welcomed thousands of refugees from various countries over the years, significantly changing the town’s demographics and supporting local businesses.

These communities often implement programs to help with integration, language barriers, and housing challenges, with the goal of leveraging the economic benefits that immigrants and refugees provide, such as starting businesses and filling labor demands.”

I mention this as we are a nation of immigrants. Immigrants of all types. Yet, being an immigrant has placed a target on people’s back under this administration. Legally documented and undocumented immigrants are getting corralled like cattle without due process. Yet, the above shows that more than a few communities see the economic benefit of immigrants. The US president should know this, but immigration is also accretive to GDP.

Just a few US immigrants in science and math

Earlier this month, I wrote a post highlighting the accretive nature of immigration to the US economy, citing a handful of examples. Below is a more detailed list I found through an Ai Search Summary, which offers some data to a few of the examples. Just leaf through the list to get a sense of the breadth of their influence.

“Astronomy

Bart Bok – Born and raised in The Netherland. Became a U.S. citizen in 1938.[172]
Margaret Burbidge – Born in the United Kingdom. Became a U.S. citizen in 1977.
Betül Kaçar
Janet Akyüz Mattei
Feryal Özel
Otto Struve – Born in Russian Empire (modern day Ukraine). Became an American citizen in 1927.

Biology

Ivet Bahar
Salvador Luria – Born and raised in Italy. Became a U.S. citizen in 1947.
Gökhan S. Hotamisligil
Ahmet Yıldız

Chemistry

Nihat Berker
Albert Chan
Basudeb DasSarma – Born in India (modern day Bangladesh). Became a U.S. citizen in 1972.
Aziz Sancar


Economics

Abhijit Banerjee
W. Michael Blumenthal – Born and raised in Germany. Became a U.S. citizen in 1952.
Michele Boldrin
John Kenneth Galbraith – Born and raised in Canada. Became an American citizen in 1937.
Faruk Gül
Asim Ijaz Khwaja
Murat Iyigun
Naci Mocan
Franco Modigliani – Born and raised in Italy. Became a U.S. citizen in 1946.
Salih Neftçi
Tayfun Sönmez


Engineering

Roma Agrawal
Ali Akansu
Ilkay Altintas
Viktor Belenko – Born and raised in Russia. Became an American citizen in 1980.
Lodewijk van den Berg – Born and raised in The Netherlands. Became a U.S. citizen in 1975.
Burcin Becerik-Gerber
Wernher von Braun – Born in Germany. Became a U.S. citizen in 1955.[173]
Tuncer Cebeci
Zeynep Çelik-Butler
Philip K. Chapman – Born and raised in Australia. Became a U.S. citizen in the late 1960s.
Kalpana Chawla – Born in India. Became an American citizen in 1991.
Ali Erdemir
Okan Ersoy
Walter Haeussermann – Born and raised in Germany. Became a U.S. citizen in 1954.
Pınar Keskinocak
Alexey Pajitnov
Thuan Pham
Jesco von Puttkamer – Born and raised in Germany. Became a U.S. citizen in 1967.
Ben Rich
Andy Thomas – Born and raised in Australia. Became a U.S. citizen in 1986.
Mehmet Toner


Mathematics

Asuman Aksoy
Lamberto Cesari – Born and raised in Italy. became an American citizen in 1976.
Bang-Yen Chen
Samuel Eilenberg
Ernst Hellinger – Born and raised in Germany. Became a U.S. citizen in 1944.
Mark Kac – Born in the Russian Empire (modern day Ukraine). Became an America citizen in 1943.
Leonid Khachiyan – Born and raised in the Soviet Union (modern day Russia). Became a U.S. citizen in 2000.
Emil Leon Post
John von Neumann – Born and raised in Hungary. Became an American citizen in 1937.
Albert Nijenhuis – Born and raised in the Netherlands. Became a U.S. citizen in 1959.
Ida Rhodes
Ayşe Şahinr
Sema Salur
Halil Mete Soner
Stanisław Ulam – Born in Austria-Hungary (modern day Ukraine). Became a U.S. citizen in 1941.

Medicine

Gertie F. Marx – Born and raised in Germany. Emigrated to New York in 1937 and became a U.S. citizen sometime after.

Meteorology

James Murdoch Austin – Born and raised in New Zealand. Became a U.S. citizen in 1946.[174]

Philosophy

Hannah Arendt
Max Black – Born in Azerbaijan raised in the United Kingdom. Became a U.S. citizen in 1948.

Physics

Ilesanmi Adesida
Qanta A. Ahmed – Born and raised in the United Kingdom (specially England). Became a U.S. citizen in 2015.
Ernest Ambler – Born and raised in the United Kingdom (specially England). Became an American citizen in 1957.
Muzaffer Atac
Bülent Atalay
Felix Bloch – Born and raised in Switzerland. Became a U.S. citizen in 1939.
Asım Orhan Barut
Ernest Courant
F. J. Duarte
Robley Dunglison – Born in the United Kingdom. Became a U.S. citizen in 1838.
Taner Edis
Albert Einstein – Born in Germany. Became a U.S. citizen in 1940.
Federico Faggin – Born and raised in Italy. Became an American citizen in 1968.
Enrico Fermi – Born and raised in Italy. Became a U.S. citizen in 1944.
André Frédéric Cournand – Born and raised in France. Became an American citizen in 1941.
Jim Yong Kim
Burçin Mutlu-Pakdil
Bennet Omalu – Born and raised in Nigeria. Became a U.S. citizen in 2015.[175]
Yuri Orlov – Born and raised in the Soviet Union (modern day Russia). Became a U.S. citizen in 1993.[176]
Benjamin B. Rubinstein – Born in Finland. Became a U.S. citizen in 1957.
Wolfgang Pauli – Born and raised in Austria-Hungary (modern day Austria). Became a U.S. citizen in 1946.
Horst Ludwig Störmer
Leana Wen – Born in China. Became a U.S. citizen in 2003.
Emil Wolf
Xiaoxing Xi

Psychology

Ozlem Ayduk
Carola B. Eisenberg – Born in Argentina. Became a U.S. citizen in 1949.
Erik Erikson
Peter Harzem
Boris M. Levinson – Born in the Russian Empire (modern day Lithuania). Became a U.S. citizen in 1930.
Renee Rabinowitz
Douglas G. Stuart – Born in Australia. Became an American citizen in 1961.
Max Wertheimer”

One of the lessons which is lost on too many leaders is you never know where good ideas may originate. Another is people who immigrate to the US are often more entrepreneurial on average than Americans. Risking the journey to a new country is evidence of this. Plus, many of these folks are more educated than the positions they find themselves in. They view a poor job as a starting point.

I understand the argument over illegal immigrants, but they are ingrained in hiring in more than several industries. If leaders did not want them here, why were employers allowed to hire them? Rather than rounding people up like cattle under a presumption they are here illegally, having a plan to integrate people, follow due process, and be humane is not too much to ask. Doing anything for political reasons is usually not a good recipe for well-thought out execution.

Some Successful Immigrants to US

Immigrants bring innovation and an entrepreneurial bent to the US. Their efforts also are accretive to our economy. Even illegal immigrants are ingrained in more than several industries. Per an AI Search Summary:

“Successful immigrants in America come from diverse backgrounds and excel in many fields, including tech (Sergey Brin, Elon Musk), entertainment (Arnold Schwarzenegger, Salma Hayek, Mila Kunis), science (Albert Einstein, Mario Molina), business (Indra Nooyi), and politics (Madeleine Albright, Pramila Jayapal), demonstrating significant contributions to the economy, culture, and innovation, with many founding major companies like Google, Apple, and Amazon, notes the American Immigration Council.”

Just focusing on Tech & Business Leaders, the same AI Search Summary reveals the following successes:

“Sergey Brin: Co-founder of Google (Russia).
Elon Musk: Founder of SpaceX, Tesla (South Africa/Canada).
Jensen Huang: Co-founder of Nvidia (Taiwan).
Andrew Cherng: Co-founder of Panda Restaurant Group (China).
Indra Nooyi: Former CEO of PepsiCo (India).
Jan Koum: Co-founder of WhatsApp (Ukraine).

Science & Academia
Albert Einstein: Nobel Prize-winning physicist (Germany).
Nikola Tesla: Inventor of AC motor (Croatia/Serbia).
Kalpana Chawla: First Indian-American astronaut (India).
Gebisa Ejeta: World Food Prize Laureate, geneticist (Ethiopia).”

We could also mix in names like Wernher Von Braun (Rocket Science), Enrico Fermi (Nuclear Science), and John Kenneth Galbraith (Economics) and Steve Jobs (Apple). Von Braun led the development of our rockets for NASA, Fermi was instrumental in the development of the atomic bomb, and Jobs was instrumental in the creation of Apple Computers. Galbraith was a forward thinker in economics.

For those who want to curtail immigration, let me respond with an observation I read – ideas come from unexpected sources. Leaders must allow for the flow of ideas from such sources, as quite often they come from people closest to the action. This observation comes from the CEO of Alcoa, Paul O’Neill who came in and turned around their troubles. Just leaf through the list above and research their contributions.

Finally, there are a few communities in the US who have been dying off with plant closures. After struggling, they advertised for immigrants to come to their communities and offer new ideas. I found this to be a nice counterpoint to a restrictive mindset under the current regime.

Immigration crackdown causing labor shortages


In an article by Michael Sainato in The Guardian called “US workers say Trump’s immigration crackdown is causing labor shortages: ‘A strain on everybody’” an unsurprising story is told. The subtitle tells more: “As Trump moves to strip over 1 million immigrants of legal status, factories grapple with slowdowns, say employees.”

Here are two paragraphs that shed more light:


“Donald Trump’s crackdown on immigration is piling pressure on US factories, according to employees and union leaders, as veteran workers from overseas are forced to leave their jobs.

As economists warn the administration’s full-scale deportation ambitions could ultimately cost millions of jobs, workers at two sites – in Michigan and Kentucky – told the Guardian that industrial giants are grappling with labor shortages.”

Too many industries and employers rely on both legal and illegal immigrants. So, crackdown to deal with both his harmful to our economy and ultimately jobs in now struggling companies. Kicking out folks with legal status is both wrong and asinine. Rounding up illegal immigrants may be more legitimate, but these folks need due process and should be treated better than they are. Irrespective, they also are holding up various industries who hired them.

Being thoughtful about immigration is a more serious subject. It deserves both analytics and empathy. Efforts like the bipartisan Senate bill that passed thanks to the “Gang of Eight,” could have passed in the House. That bill of twelve years or so ago was never brought up for a vote as it was better to not be passed for campaign reasons.

So, we have a problem now that is antagonistic to growth and jobs. And, it has been created because no one analyzed what might happen.