Thom Tillis vs. the Trump administration
By Frank Bruni
******************
“What does it look and sound like when a Republican lawmaker who has mostly been a cheerleader for Team Trump trades his pompoms for a shiv?
Senator Thom Tillis is showing us. And it’s a glorious spectacle.
In a recent exchange with reporters in Washington, the North Carolina Republican didn’t merely say that Kristi Noem, the homeland security secretary, had made “amateurish” mistakes. He stressed that he couldn’t think of a single thing she’d done over the past year that she can be proud of.
His appraisal of another senior administration official was no gentler. ‘Stephen Miller never fails to live up to my expectations of incompetence,’ Tillis said.
But the real beauty? The sign that Tillis was uncapping a deep well of disgust and reveling in the release? He composed an ornate, irate social media post of roughly 200 words in which he expounded on the meaning of ‘sycophant’ and explained why the slur fit Miller and Noem so snugly.
‘Common Synonyms: toady, flunky, bootlicker,’ Tillis wrote. He invoked ‘The Lord of the Rings’ movie trilogy to assert that Miller resembles Grima Wormtongue, who ‘uses his position to poison a leader’s standing for his own benefit.’ Tillis added that Noem is a ringer for Dolores Umbridge in the Harry Potter movies, who ‘sucks up to authority to gain the power she needs to bully those ‘beneath’ her.’
There’s going rogue, and then there’s going rogue with a thesaurus in one hand and a movie glossary in the other. Tillis seems intent on making his complaints about the Trump administration’s errors and overreach as memorable as possible.
He also seems to be having a blast.
There he was on CNBC’s “Squawk Box” on Wednesday morning, mischief in his voice as he called the Justice Department’s investigation of Jerome Powell, the chair of the Federal Reserve Board, ‘frivolous,’ ‘vindictive’ and ‘trumped-up.’
And there he was on Politico’s ‘The Conversation’ the week before that, his eyes twinkling as he mused about the bafflingly low profile and dubious utility of Tulsi Gabbard, the director of national intelligence. ‘I don’t know if she’s in, like, the F.B.I. witness protection program,’ he said.
He’s sassing. He’s smiling. The liberation of a conscience does wonders for a man.
Partial liberation, I should say. Even now, Tillis focuses most of his pique on the people around President Trump rather than the president himself, who’s the victim, in Tillis’s telling, of ‘bad advice.’ And Tillis goes out of his way to cast his candor as faithful service to Trump and the Republican Party, which could suffer a serious setback in the midterm elections.
‘I want this president to be the most successful Republican president in the history of this country,’ he said on ‘The Conversation.’ ‘His success is intrinsically linked to the success of Republicans this November.’
Tillis, 65, is no profile in unfettered courage. He’s in the final year of his second term and not running for re-election, so he needn’t worry about some ultra-MAGA hellion taking him on in a primary and getting Trump’s endorsement.
He also bears some responsibility for all the damage the Trump administration has done. He voted to confirm Noem, Gabbard, Robert F. Kennedy Jr., Kash Patel and, most notoriously, Pete Hegseth, whose bid to become defense secretary Tillis reportedly tried to scuttle until Trump made the magnitude of his displeasure with that clear.
But over recent weeks, Tillis has reconnected with a past version of himself, the spirited maverick who found common cause with Democrats and emphasized common sense over strident partisanship. It’s a version that he never fully interred: After Trump pardoned rioters who invaded the U.S. Capitol and assaulted law enforcement officers on Jan. 6, 2021, Tillis gave an impassioned speech on the Senate floor protesting that decision.
But that spasm of rebellion was nothing like Tillis’s current tear. On ‘The Conversation,’ he questioned the logic of many of the tariffs Trump imposed, harshly criticized the president’s huffing and puffing about Greenland, fretted over Trump’s estrangement of Canada and the European Union, and said that ‘anybody who thinks that NATO is passé and should go doesn’t understand the democratic world order.’
He also said that if the Justice Department is going to torment Powell for supposedly spending too lavishly on renovations of the Federal Reserve’s headquarters, ‘then I want to see the details of the East Wing cost, maybe even the cost of the Qatar jet, upfitting it to be a fake Air Force One.’
‘I mean, we can go all over the place if we want to start talking about efficiency,’ Tillis added.
Dasha Burns, the host of ‘The Conversation,’ noted that Trump had called Tillis and Senator Lisa Murkowski, Republican of Alaska, “losers” for having denigrated Noem. Burns asked Tillis for his response.
He shrugged off the insult, saying it was the stuff of ‘junior high school,’ and likened it to “arm farts.”
I’ve heard some political observers speculate that Tillis is selfishly looking ahead to a post-Trump era when Republicans who raised alarms about the president’s policies and conduct will be rewarded for that or at least judged more kindly by history. Maybe so.
But Tillis will certainly have to weather ample ugliness from the MAGA faithful in the meantime. Just ask Mitt Romney, Liz Cheney, Adam Kinzinger. So I choose to compliment him. To thank him. And to hope that his example encourages some of the toadies, flunkies and bootlickers in the halls of Congress to rethink their sycophancy.”
I called Tillis and left him a two-part message. First, I thanked him for being more critical of the White House Administration. Second, I reiterated early comments that in all my years of consulting, I have observed organizations take on the personality of their leader. The leader sets the bar on bad and good behavior. Trump’s people name call, label, bully, lie and act rashly because their boss does all those things. It really is that simple. Just listen to a part of the embarrassing and vitriolic comments made yesterday by the Attorney General under oath.